Manuscript Review Form
Global Journal of Multidisciplinary Studies and Technological Innovations (GJMSTI)
Manuscript Review Form
Manuscript Information
Manuscript ID: __________________________
Manuscript Title: ____________________________________________________________
Date Received: __________________________
Date Reviewed: __________________________
Reviewer Name: ____________________________________________________________
Affiliation: ________________________________________________________________
Email Address: ____________________________________________________________
Section A: Evaluation Criteria
Please rate the manuscript based on the following criteria using the scale:
5 = Excellent | 4 = Good | 3 = Average | 2 = Poor | 1 = Very Poor | N/A = Not Applicable
|
Criteria |
Rating (1–5 / N/A) |
Comments (Optional) |
|
Originality / Novelty of the Research |
|
|
|
Scientific/Technical Quality and Rigor |
|
|
|
Relevance to Journal Scope |
|
|
|
Clarity and Organization of the Manuscript |
|
|
|
Literature Review and Referencing |
|
|
|
Methodology – Appropriateness and Description |
|
|
|
Data Analysis and Interpretation |
|
|
|
Significance of Results / Conclusions |
|
|
|
English Language and Grammar |
|
|
|
Ethical Considerations (if applicable) |
|
|
Section B: Reviewer Comments to the Authors
Please provide specific, constructive feedback to help the authors improve the manuscript.
> _______________________________________________________________________________
> _______________________________________________________________________________
> _______________________________________________________________________________
> _______________________________________________________________________________
> _______________________________________________________________________________
Section C: Confidential Comments to the Editor
(Optional: These comments will not be shared with the authors)
> _______________________________________________________________________________
> _______________________________________________________________________________
> _______________________________________________________________________________
Section D: Recommendation
Please select one of the following options:
☐ Accept without revisions
☐ Accept with minor revisions
☐ Major revisions required
☐ Reject – Not suitable for publication
☐ Refer to another journal
Reviewer Declaration
☐ I declare that I have no conflict of interest related to this manuscript.
☐ I agree to keep the content of the manuscript confidential.
Signature: _________________________
Date: _________________________
